Neither, by much. Across 25,413 player-weeks since 2019, ESPN’s weekly projections missed by 5.62 points a player and RotoWire’s by 5.64, in full PPR, and since 2021 they’ve been within a tenth of a point at every position. The useful difference is when they disagree: when the two were 3 or more points apart, the lower projection was closer 58% of the time. Averaging them was as good as the better one.
ESPN builds its own projections. RotoWire’s are the ones Sleeper shows its players: every line in Sleeper’s projection feed is labeled RotoWire. They’re two of the most-used projections in fantasy football, and they don’t always agree. So I set them side by side: every weekly projection from both, 2019 through Week 10 of 2026, for quarterbacks, running backs, receivers and tight ends, against what each player scored.
How different are ESPN and RotoWire?
Not very. Their projections for the same player in the same week line up at r = 0.93, and they’re 1.3 points apart on average. Quarterbacks split the most (1.7 points apart) and tight ends the least (1.1). Only 7.7% of player-weeks had them 3 or more points apart.
Which one misses less?
They’re tied, and averaging them is a hair better than either.
- ESPN
- RotoWire
- Averaged
| ESPN | RotoWire | Averaged | |
|---|---|---|---|
| QB | 6.11 | 6.20 | 6.10 |
| RB | 5.63 | 5.59 | 5.57 |
| WR | 5.70 | 5.72 | 5.68 |
| TE | 4.91 | 4.97 | 4.91 |
The one real gap was quarterbacks in 2019–20, when ESPN missed by 6.33 points and RotoWire by 6.63. Since 2021, the two have been within 0.1 points of each other at every position. Across the four positions in each stretch, averaging them missed the least in five of eight, and was never more than 0.06 points behind the better source.
Which one ranks players better?
Also a tie. Within a week, both put players in close to the same order, and their projected top 12 or top 24 finished there about equally often.
| Position | ESPN rank | RotoWire rank | Averaged rank | ESPN top tier | RotoWire top tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| QB | 0.35 | 0.37 | 0.37 | 54.7% | 54.5% |
| RB | 0.53 | 0.52 | 0.54 | 63.7% | 63.7% |
| WR | 0.46 | 0.46 | 0.47 | 48.9% | 48.9% |
| TE | 0.38 | 0.37 | 0.39 | 49.1% | 49.1% |
RotoWire ranked quarterbacks slightly better since 2021 (0.37 to 0.35; they were even in 2019–20), and ESPN ranked tight ends slightly better in both stretches. Averaging ranked best at every position, and in each stretch but one: tight ends in 2019–20, where ESPN was a hair ahead.
Who wins when they disagree?
This is where it pays to look at both. When ESPN and RotoWire were 3 or more points apart on a player, the lower projection was closer to what he scored 58% of the time.
| Lower projection closer | |
|---|---|
| QB | 59% |
| RB | 60% |
| WR | 56% |
| TE | 60% |
That held in both stretches of seasons (58% in 2019–20 and in 2021–26) and at every position, from 56% for receivers to 60% for running backs and tight ends. Which site was closer did not hold up: ESPN won 55% of those splits in 2019–20 but 49% since 2021. So the useful rule isn’t “trust ESPN” or “trust RotoWire.” It’s “when they split, lean to the lower number.”
What about defenses?
Same story. ESPN and RotoWire were close at ranking team defenses too, and averaging the two ranked them best. The details, in standard scoring and in CUTLINE’s impact plays, are in How well do ESPN and RotoWire rank NFL fantasy defenses?
What should you do?
- Use either one: they miss by nearly the same at every position.
- Better, average them. It was as good as the better source, without having to guess which one that is.
- When they’re 3 or more points apart on a player, lean to the lower projection.
- For how far off any projection tends to be, by position, see How accurate are fantasy football projections by position?
CUTLINE’s Capline prices every player from ESPN’s and RotoWire’s projections averaged, for the same reason.
How this was computed
- Projections: each week’s line from ESPN and RotoWire, scored in full PPR from the projected stats. These are the lines the sources still serve for past weeks. RotoWire’s come from Sleeper’s projection feed, which labels every line RotoWire.
- Players: quarterbacks, running backs, receivers and tight ends projected 5 or more points (the two averaged) with a line from both: 25,413 player-weeks across 134 weeks, 2019 through Week 10 of 2026. A projected player who didn’t play scored 0.
- Average miss: the average gap between projected and actual points.
- Rank correlation: within each week and position, how closely the projected order matched the actual order (1 is perfect, 0 is none), averaged over weeks.
- Top tier: of each week’s 12 highest-projected quarterbacks and tight ends or 24 running backs and receivers, the share that finished in that week’s top 12 or 24 among everyone who played.
- Splits: player-weeks where the two were 3 or more points apart: 1,953 of them. “Closer” is the smaller gap to the actual score.
- Stretches: 2019–20 and 2021–26 (2021 began the 17-game seasons). Each claim here holds in both unless the text says otherwise.
Data: game stats from nflverse; projections from ESPN, and from RotoWire as Sleeper serves them.



